Member Center: Welcome, | Logout | My Account | Log In / Register | Help
heraldonline
High | Low
Currently: °
More Weather | Traffic
Customer Service
Adam_ODaniel's picture

Fort Mill makes national headlines

Look at you, Fort Mill High, Mr. Big Time on the national news.

Since The Herald broke the story Monday about six people being thrown in jail for cheering out of turn at the Yellow Jackets' graduation, and a seventh at York's ceremony, news outlets from here to San Diego have picked up the story. The headline was on the "Most Viewed Stories" list at FoxNews.com yesterday.

The story has also been fodder for some playful reporting, too. Like this morning when a reporter on Charlotte's WBT radio said, "Graduations begin for CMS schools today, where officials say disruptions will be asked to leave. But they won't be thrown in jail, like the six people in Fort Mill."

Not sure if that's the kind of publicity South Carolina's golden child of school districts was hoping for. On the other hand, if making a strong statement about disrupting a graduation ceremony was the goal, it certainly has been achieved.

Here's the dilemma: Everyone deserves to be cheered, congratulated or to have their nickname screamed from on high for completing high school, especially in a state with a notoriously low graduation rate. But everyone deserves to hear their name called during the ceremony, too. I was at a Winthrop graduation recently where some of the "spontaneous expressions of pleasure" — as the Winthrop program called them (sounds like it came out of a dirty magazine) — prevented the audience from hearing some of the other names. That's not fair to the quiet family who is just as proud of their son or daughter.

So, geniuses who have been talking about this around the water cooler this week, what's the solution? Some of the best ideas come from regular folks, not stuffy officials. Tell me, how can local schools avoid putting people in jail while still letting graduates and their families celebrate the moment?

These are adults??

These people were rude and inconsiderate. It's unfortunate the the national news gave the impression that all SC people are this way. I don't think they should have been arrested. Being lead out and fined should be enough. I guess we need to take into consideration that the ones who yelled out were so happy to see their child graduate, since mom and dad can't read it was a great accomplishment.

Graduation Arrests

I attended Clover's graduation ceremonies to see my daughter graduate. It was a very dignified and well organized event without one incident taking place. I am very impressed with our community's leadership, class and support which has made this past year a success at Clover High School. It was very unfortunate to hear about the incidents that took place at Fort Mill's and Northwestern's graduation ceremonies. Everyone in attendance should have been well aware of the consequences by not following the rules. Those people who chose not to follow the rules should be held responsible. I know that it can be distracting and annoying to hear someone screaming and yelling during the ceremonies, but it can also be distracting witnessing a non-resisting person being led away by law enforcement in handcuffs during the ceremonies. I feel that better enforcement procedures could have taken place without causing further distraction. In the future, the proper procedure for officers should be to ask the person to come with them to be escorted away from the premises. Restraint should only be used if resistance takes place. I only hope that this year's events could be a learning tool for both York County Schools and York County Law Enforcement Officials. One final note, congratulations to all of the 2008 York County High School graduates and to their families.

Graduation Arrests

As a tax payer, I find this to be a total misuse of law enforcement and judicial resources. Exactly how much is it going to cost us to process these "offenders"? Let's use $5,000 each? That's about $35,000 for seven, it's not cheap; the police, paperwork, jail time, going to court. In my opinion this money should be spent in making our towns safer. Next time we don't have money for a police officer, think about this waste of money.

Arresting people at a graduation ceremony like this is ridiculous. Whatever happened to a verbal reminder during the ceremony to be quiet. You can bet there were small children attending the event that were disruptive as well. Nothing worse than a loud toddler or a crying baby. Are we going to start arresting parents for disorderly conduct?

South Carolina School Districts need to step up and get more students graduating. Graduation rates are extremely low for SC. We better get more friends and family cheering at graduations and get kids through school.

About the Fort Mill High School Graduation Arrests I WAS THERE!!

I WAS THERE AS A FORT MILL HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATE THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I'M GOING TO COLLEGE TO BECOME A POLICE OFFICER. So to see your opinion INSULTS ME!!! Yes there were young children there and crying babies but EVERY STUDENT DESERVES TO HEAR THEIR NAME CALLED. Do you know how hard some to those students worked to get to were they are now. THERE WERE 535 STUDENTS GRADUATING!!! I mean come on if we let people cheer for everyone we would've been there until 5 or 6 o'clock and not to mention South Pointe graduated at 2 o'clock and Clover at 7. Fort Mill had the largest graduating class EVER!!! So I do think the arrests were nessesary. I mean they could've just been escorted out to the building but if they refused to leave THEN and ONLY THEN were they arrested. I even saw one person not only refuse to leave but resist arrest by pulling away from the arresting officer cutting the officer with the cuffs. Yes the officer did cut himself but that wouldn't have happened if the person didn't pull away.

In conclusion I have just one question to ask..........
DO YOU KNOW HOW ANNOYING IT IS TO HEAR PEOPLE YELL AND CHEER WHILE YOU'RE TRYING TO HEAR YOUR NAME CALLED?.........DO YOU!!??

HAVE SOME RESPECT FOR ALL THE GRADUATES!

Michaelprocton's picture

Three points...

A. There WERE verbal reminders, as well as written reminders.

B. Small children (toddlers, etc.) have limited ability to control themselves or to understand any disruption they may cause. Adults should be fully able to maintain proper decorum at a ceremony like this, particularly if they have been informed of the rules.

C. If kids need obnoxious supporters at their graduation to motivate them to complete their high school education, then it's probably not worth it for them to do so in the first place.

Adam_ODaniel's picture

Free speech but...

Lots of good points on both sides of this debate. Here's another one from Charlie in Catawba who just called me on the phone:

Charlie said he attended the Northwestern High graduation where the same rules were in place and people behaved. He said he disagrees with radio host Rush Limbaugh, who defended the people arrested earlier this week.

"It was the best graduation I ever attended," Charlie said.

"I like free speech, but dammit, I wanna hear the names called at a graduation."

Michaelprocton's picture

Amen, Charlie

The moment those people had been escorted from the proceedings would have drawn my biggest cheer of the night.

poppers's picture

Children were kept quiet as well

Daughter graduated last year and when a small child began to get squirmy and then became noisy, a cop edged closer and closer. The woman, unable to calm the child down, took him outside. It was the greatest thing I ever saw. When growing up going to church, moms and dads would hustle their noisy kids outside so as not to disturb the others. It was called COURTESY! Simple, plain, ordinary common courtesy to not spoil an event for others.

If we could thus empower theater ushers, I'd enjoy going to the movies again. Hell, I'd love to see a cop walking up and down the aisles, billy-clubbing the shins of adolescent seat-kickers.

poppers's picture

Answer: Sit Down and Shaddap!

You are warned by the announcer, and by the written program, to be silent as the names are read, and what the consequences will be. There is ample opportunity to applaud after all the names are read. It is really that simple.

I didn't read or hear anything about the fact that there were arrests last year and, I think, the year before. Also missing in the story is context. Attending the ceremonies at Winthrop, how many schools with how many parents were able to respect the rules out of consideration for others? Thousands, I would guess, against six idiots.

Rush Limbaugh opened his radio program with the story yesterday. He was being a jack-ass about it, I suppose because it was a chance for him to mindlessly rip public education. But he accidentally made a good point, as he facetiously wondered what we would do about noisy parents at a pep rally. Graduation IS NOT a pep rally, dummy. That is the point! Celebrate loud and long, wherever you like, after the ceremony. But keep in mind that if it gets out of hand, you can be arrested for that as well. Get it?

High School graduation is about the achievement of three parties: the school, the parents and, most importantly, the child. Teachers see it every year, parents often experience it with other family members, but it is an extra special occasion for the students because, for them, it only happens once in a lifetime. This coming of age event is a huge part of our culture and it should be a dignified, mature ceremony.

One suggestion, though, would be to remove the disrespectful and ask them to leave the premises. Arrest them only if they resist.

Adam_ODaniel's picture

More context on graduation

Here's a link to Principal Dee Christopher's statement for those who want to know more details.

http://www.fort-mill.k12.sc.us/home.aspx

Another link to the Rock Hill School Board blog, also weighing in on the issue, even though its not directly related to their schools.

http://districtthreeed.blogspot.com/

freethought's picture

Hmm...


Rush Limbaugh opened his radio program with the story yesterday. He was being a jack-ass about it, I suppose because it was a chance for him to mindlessly rip public education.

Question:

When is Limpballs not a jack-ass?

"Tantum religio potuit suadere malorum."
~ Lucretius, De Rerum Natura

poppers's picture

An A for the Q from Freethought

From the closed mind of "Freethought" :

Question:

When is Limpballs not a jack-ass?

....................................................

Answer:

00.01% of the time, much to the chagrin of his philosophical and political enemies, as well as those who often agree with him. It's entertaining.

freethought's picture

Entertaining?

You may prefer to find the deluded rantings of a hillbilly heroin addict amusing. Personally, I can't see why any one would find his"phony soldure" remarks or when he mimicked Michael J. Fox Parkinson's entertaining...

Then again, I don't need some racist junkie telling me what I need to think...

"Tantum religio potuit suadere malorum."
~ Lucretius, De Rerum Natura

JSchonberg's picture

re: graduation arrests

You could do what I did and go to Quaker school. Our graduation was a "silent meeting."

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.